Canadian politics, policy & the country's place in the world

VideoU.S.–Canada

Musk tells Carney to diversify away from Starlink as Canada builds alternatives

Canada's reliance on a single American satellite network raises questions about who controls military communications in the Arctic and during wartime.

Published

Summary

Elon Musk told the New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18 that countries should "Diversify away. Don't use Starlink." His remark answered a question from host Andrew Ross Sorkin, who raised Mark Carney's concern about who decides whether Starlink, or its military version Starshield, stays switched on during a war. Musk said he would not change the speed limit on Starlink in Ukraine, and that Starshield is controlled by the US government.

Canada had already acted. On August 4, the Defence Investment Agency signed a $2.3 billion contract with Telesat for secure military communications across the Arctic. The day after Musk's remarks, Dominion Dynamics announced a $2.2 million deal with Telesat for two rugged, portable antennas, and on Friday it named twelve Canadian partners for its Scout combat drone.

The video also weighs the risks. Telesat's satellites will launch on SpaceX rockets, but the presenter argues that a launch does not give SpaceX control over what the satellites carry or when they switch off. Telesat's older satellite business also carries about $3.1 billion in debt due between December 2026 and October 2027, and its creditors have set a January 18, 2027 deadline to reorganize it.

Key points

  • Musk said "Diversify away. Don't use Starlink" at the New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18.
  • Zelensky said on November 17 that speed limits on Starshield were still in place over Russian-occupied territory.
  • The Defence Investment Agency signed a contract worth $2.3 billion with Telesat on August 4 for Arctic military communications.
  • With two five-year options, the Telesat contract can reach $2.7 billion over 15 years.
  • Dominion Dynamics and Telesat announced a $2.2 million deal for two rugged, portable antennas.
  • Telesat's older satellite business faces about $3.1 billion in debt due between December 2026 and October 2027.

Questions answered

What did Elon Musk say about Starlink and Canada?

At the New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18, Musk replied "Diversify away. Don't use Starlink" after host Andrew Ross Sorkin raised Mark Carney's views. Musk also said people had pressured him to change Starlink's speed limit in Ukraine, and that he was not changing it.

What is the Telesat contract Canada signed?

On August 4, the Defence Investment Agency signed a contract worth $2.3 billion with Telesat. It provides secure military communications for the Canadian Armed Forces across the Arctic, from 65 degrees North to the Pole. With two five-year options, it can reach $2.7 billion over 15 years.

Does launching satellites on SpaceX rockets mean SpaceX controls them?

According to the video, no. A rocket is a ride, and once satellites reach orbit SpaceX has no say over what they carry or when they switch off. That decision sits with the operator. Telesat booked 14 launches on SpaceX's Falcon 9 in 2023.

Watch on YouTube Subscribe

Prepared by the CanadaNext Editor with AI assistance from public reporting and CanadaNext's own videos. Sources are linked. How we work