VideoU.S.–Canada
Canadian support for a US trade deal with tariffs falls from 41% to 33%
Support for a deal that keeps tariffs fell as talks resume, leaving Ottawa to decide whether to sign a possible deal or hold out for better terms.
Summary
A Nanos Research poll for CTV News found that 33.3% of Canadians would support a trade deal with the United States that still includes tariffs. A similar survey in August 2025 had found 41%. The video links the drop to Ottawa's decision in August to walk away from an American offer, which 85% of Canadians supported or somewhat supported in a follow-up poll, and to talks that are now resuming.
Barry Appleton, an international trade lawyer, argues that Canadians feel more loved because Europe, the Philippines, ASEAN and India are all courting Canada, giving voters other options. Against that, the video notes that seven in ten dollars of exports still go to the United States, and Mary Scott Greenwood says zero tariffs is unlikely. Still, most Canadian goods cross tariff-free under CUSMA, and the overall effective tariff rate is about 5%.
The video compares Canada with the European Union and Japan, which accepted a 15% tariff ceiling in 2025. After the US Supreme Court struck down emergency tariffs on February 20, 2026, new forced-labour tariffs and a second investigation kept testing those limits. The host frames the choice for Ottawa as whether to accept a permanent tariff near 5% or hold out for better terms.
Key points
- Nanos Research for CTV News found 33.3% of Canadians would support a US trade deal that still includes tariffs.
- A similar August 2025 Nanos survey found 41% would accept such a deal.
- Nanos polled 1,058 adults between October 31 and November 2, with a margin of error of three points.
- 85% supported or somewhat supported Canada's decision to walk away from the August offer.
- Most Canadian goods still cross the border tariff-free under CUSMA.
- Canada's overall effective tariff rate is about 5%. The US Supreme Court struck down the emergency tariffs on February 20, 2026.
Questions answered
How much Canadian support is there for a trade deal with the US that includes tariffs?
A Nanos Research poll for CTV News, conducted October 31 to November 2, found 33.3% of 1,058 adults would support a US trade deal that still includes tariffs. A similar August 2025 survey found 41%. The poll has a margin of error of three points.
What is Canada's effective tariff rate under the current US tariffs?
The video says Canada's overall effective tariff rate, meaning the average duty actually paid across everything Canada ships south, is about 5%. Most Canadian goods still cross the border tariff-free under CUSMA. Mary Scott Greenwood says zero tariffs is unlikely under the current US administration.
What did the EU and Japan agree to in their US tariff deals?
Both accepted an American tariff ceiling of 15% on most exports. Japan also pledged $550 billion of investment in the United States. After the Supreme Court struck down the emergency tariffs, new forced-labour tariffs of 10% for the EU and 12.5% for Japan were announced, and a second investigation kept testing the caps.
Will Canada and the US reach a trade deal before the end of 2026?
US Ambassador Pete Hoekstra predicted on November 4 that the two countries could reach a deal before the end of 2026. The video notes Trump's threatened 50% tariff on Canadian cars, trucks, parts and steel is set for January 1.
Prepared by the CanadaNext Editor with AI assistance from public reporting and CanadaNext's own videos. Sources are linked. How we work