VideoU.S.–Canada
Former NAFTA negotiator Carla Hills tells US court Section 338 Canada tariff law is dead
At stake is whether a 1938 Canada-U.S. trade pact can help overturn a 50% tariff on Canadian goods, with a hearing set for January 20, 2027.
Summary
A legal brief filed in the U.S. Court of International Trade in Manhattan says Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 is not dormant but dead. The law is the one Donald Trump used to impose a 50% tariff on Canadian goods. The case was brought by Gellert Global Group, a New Jersey cheese importer that asks the court to strike down the tariffs and refund what it paid.
Amicus briefs followed from November 11 to 13. Carla Hills, Alan Wolff and Warren Maruyama say section 338 was never considered while section 301 was being written, and that it is missing from House trade law compilations from 1989 to 2010. Advancing American Freedom, the group Mike Pence founded, argues that Americans pay tariffs. Robert Zoellick and Philip Zelikow argue that Canada's 1935 and 1938 equal-treatment agreements with Washington place it outside Section 338.
The video argues that Canada's counter tariffs were a response to U.S. duties, and it contrasts China, which received Section 301 hearings, with Canada, which received none. The Justice Department must respond by December 11, and the hearing is set for January 20, 2027. The video asks whether Ottawa should file its own brief before then.
Key points
- Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 has so far been used only against Canada, according to the video.
- The Hills brief says the law is missing from every House Ways and Means trade law compilation from 1989 to 2010.
- The brief says none of 19 chief U.S. trade lawyers over those decades ever mentioned using it.
- Canada signed equal-treatment agreements with Washington on November 15, 1935 and November 17, 1938.
- The Hills brief says China charges American goods an average tariff of 31.9%, against 7.5% for everyone else.
- The Justice Department must respond by December 11; the hearing is set for January 20, 2027.
Questions answered
What is Section 338 and why is it in court?
Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 is the law Trump used to put a 50% tariff on Canadian goods. Gellert Global Group, a New Jersey cheese importer, asks the Court of International Trade to strike down the Section 338 tariffs and refund what it paid.
Why do former trade officials say Section 338 is dead?
Carla Hills, Alan Wolff and Warren Maruyama say section 338 was never considered while section 301 was being written. Their brief says it is missing from House trade law compilations from 1989 to 2010, and none of 19 chief U.S. trade lawyers mentioned using it.
How does the 1938 Canada-U.S. agreement relate to the tariff?
Robert Zoellick and Philip Zelikow argue that Canada signed equal-treatment agreements with Washington on November 15, 1935 and November 17, 1938. They argue the agreement governs disputes and the president lost the power to threaten it, so Section 338 does not apply to Canada.
Prepared by the CanadaNext Editor with AI assistance from public reporting and CanadaNext's own videos. Sources are linked. How we work